| Year | Championship Result | Location |
| 2015 | Tarleton State 66, Angelo State 64 | Stephenville, Texas |
| Other participants: Texas A&M-Commerce, Midwestern State, Metro State, St. Mary's, UC-Colorado Springs, Colorado Mines. |
| 2014 | Metropolitan State (Colo.) 78, Midwestern State 56 | Denver, Colo. |
| Other participants: Ark.-Fort Smith, Tarleton State, Texas A&M International, UC-Colorado Springs, Colorado Mines, St. Mary's. |
| 2013 | Metropolitan State (Colo.) 78, St. Mary's (Texas) 70 | Denver, Colo. |
| Other participants: Fort Lewis, Adams State, Cameron, Tarleton State, Midwestern State, Newman. |
| 2012 | Midwestern State 77, Arkansas Tech 61 | Wichita Falls, Texas |
| Other participants: West Texas A&M, Tarleton State, Missouri Southern, St. Mary's, Washburn, Northwest Missouri State. |
| 2011 | Midwestern State 73, Central Oklahoma 66 | Edmond, Okla. |
| Other participants: Missouri Southern, Fort Hays State, Texas A&M International, West Texas A&M, Washburn, Tarleton State. |
| 2010 | Midwestern State 60, Central Missouri 59 | Wichita Falls, Texas |
| Other participants: Tarleton State, Fort Hays State, Incarnate Word, Nebraska-Omaha, Missouri Western, Central Oklahoma. |
| 2009 | Central Missouri 98, Southwest Baptist 63 | Warrensburg, Mo. |
| Other participants: Midwestern State, Dallas Baptist, Texas A&M-Kingsville, Incarnate Word, Central Oklahoma, Angelo State. |
| 2008 | Central Oklahoma 77, Tarleton State 76 | Stephenville, Texas |
| Other participants: Southwest Baptist, Northwest Missouri, St. Mary's, West Texas A&M, Fort Hays State, St. Edward's. |
| 2007 | Central Missouri 67, Southeastern Oklahoma 54 | Warrensburg, Mo. |
| Other participants: Midwestern State, Northwest Missouri, Emporia State, West Texas A&M, Pittsburg State, St. Edward's. |
| 2006 | Tarleton State 72, Northwest Missouri 71 | Bolivar, Mo. |
| Other participants: Southwest Baptist, Central Missouri, Central Oklahoma, Truman, St. Edward's, West Texas A&M. |
| 2005 | Tarleton State 75, Texas A&M-Commerce 70 | Commerce, Texas |
| Other participants: Pittsburg State, Central Oklahoma, Central Missouri, St. Mary's, Washburn, Southwestern Oklahoma. |
| 2004 | Northwest Missouri 62, Drury 59 | Stephenville, Texas |
| Other participants: Tarleton State, Washburn, St. Mary's, Eastern New Mexico, Emporia State, Texas A&M-Kingsville. |
| 2003 | Northeastern State 56, Tarleton State 46 | Stephenville, Texas |
| Other participants: Washburn, Northwest Missouri, Central Oklahoma, West Texas A&M, Missouri Western, St. Mary's. |
| 2002 | Northwest Missouri 79, Rockhurst 73 | Tahlequah, Okla. |
| Other participants: Northeastern State, Incarnate Word, Tarleton State, Missouri Western. |
| 2001 | Washburn 67, Northwest Missouri 61 | Topeka, Kan. |
| Other participants: West Texas A&M, Northeastern State, Angelo State, St. Mary's. |
| 2000 | Missouri Southern 92, Midwestern State 83 | Joplin, Mo. |
| Other participants: Northeastern State, Washburn, Northwest Missouri, Drury. |
| 1999 | Truman 76, Abilene Christian 69 | Wichita Falls, Texas |
| Other participants: Midwestern State, Pittsburg State, Missouri Western, West Texas A&M. |
| 1998 | West Texas A&M 105, Central Oklahoma 101 | Canyon, Texas |
| Other participants: Missouri Western, Pittsburg State, Texas A&M-Commerce, Northwest Missouri. |
| 1997 | Texas A&M-Commerce 89, Pittsburg State 83 | Topeka, Kan. |
| Other participants: Washburn, Central Oklahoma, Central Missouri, Missouri Western. |
| 1996 | North Alabama 92, Missouri S&T 80 | Rolla, Mo. |
| Other participants: Central Missouri, Texas A&M-Kingsville, Delta State, Texas A&M-Commerce. |
| 1995 | Central Missouri 117, Central Oklahoma 112 | Warrensburg, Mo. |
| Other participants: Mississippi College, Missouri Western, Washburn, North Alabama. |
| 1994 | Washburn 92, North Alabama 73 | Topeka, Kan. |
| Other participants: Central Missouri, West Texas A&M. |
| 1993 | Washburn 79, Eastern New Mexico 78 | Edmond, Okla. |
| Other participants: Central Oklahoma, Missouri Southern. |
| 1992 | Central Oklahoma 132, Washburn 114 | Topeka, Kan. |
| Other participants: Missouri Western, Texas A&M-Kingsville. |
| 1991 | Southwest Baptist 63, Central Missouri 61 | Warrensburg, Mo. |
| Other participants: Kentucky Wesleyan, West Texas A&M. |
| 1990 | Southeast Missouri State 88, Missouri Western 73 | Cape Girardeau, Mo. |
| Other participants: West Texas A&M, Southern Indiana. |
| 1989 | Southeast Missouri State 88, Central Missouri 73 | Cape Girardeau, Mo. |
| Other partcipants: Northwest Missouri, Angelo State. |
| 1988 | Southeast Missouri State 73, Missouri-St. Louis 69 | Cape Girardeau, Mo. |
| Other participants: South Dakota State, Angelo State. |
| 1987 | Delta State 90, Southeast Missouri State 84 (OT) | Amarillo, Texas |
| Other participants: West Texas A&M, Abilene Christian. |
| 1986 | Southeast Missouri State 75, Delta State 74 | Cape Girardeau, Mo. |
| Other participants: Abilene Christian, Sam Houston State. |
| 1985 | Southeast Missouri State 67, Delta State 59 | Warrensburg, Mo. |
| Other participants: Central Missouri, Alabama A&M. |
| 1984 | Central Missouri 79, Jacksonville State 72 | Warrensburg, Mo. |
| Other participants: Columbus State, Northwest Missouri. |
| 1983 | Southeast Missouri State 74, Central Missouri 69 | Cape Girardeau, Mo. |
| Other participants: Stephen F. Austin, Tennessee-Martin. |
| 1982 | Southeast Missouri State 56, Tennessee-Martin 53 | Warrensburg, Mo. |
| Other participants: Central Missouri, Central Florida |
| 1981 | North Alabama 63, Truman 59 | Jacksonville, Ala. |
| Other participants: Jacksonville State, Lincoln (Mo.). |
| 1980 | North Alabama 77, Nicholls State 68 | Warrensburg, Mo. |
| Other participants: Central Missouri, Jacksonville State. |
| 1979 | Nicholls State 100, Rollins 87 | Thibodeaux, La. |
| Other participants: Southeast Missouri State, Truman. |
| 1978 | Lincoln (Mo.) 84, Missouri State 83 | Springfield, Mo. |
| Other participants: Mississippi College, Columbus State. |
| 1977 | North Alabama 77, Troy 70 | Florence, Ala. |
| Other participants: Lincoln (Mo.), Southern (La.). |
| 1976 | Nicholls State 90, Grambling 89 | Thibodeaux, La. |
| Other participants: Lincoln (Mo.), Missouri S&T. |
| 1975 | New Orleans 84, Lincoln (Mo.) 83 | New Orleans, La. |
| Other participants: Southern (La.), West Georgia. |